Butter Chicken 101

Butter Chicken 101

A teal bowl of butter chicken with a tandoori drumstick, beside butter naan and pickled red onion

What is butter chicken?

Smoky tandoori chicken, a luscious tomato gravy, plenty of butter, and a touch of cream. What's not to love?

Better known in India as murgh makhani, butter chicken is a relatively modern invention with a surprisingly complicated history.

Behind that familiar orange gravy lies a story of migration, ingenuity, happy accidents, and a disagreement so fierce that it ended up in court!

↑ back to the top

The Story of Butter Chicken

Map marking Peshawar and Delhi, with historic photographs of the Moti Mahal founders and the Moti Mahal restaurant

A New Beginning in Post-Partition India

When Partition forced millions of people to leave their homes, they carried their culinary traditions with them. Among them were Kundan Lal Gujral and Kundan Lal Jaggi, who had worked at Moti Mahal in Peshawar. Along with Thakur Dass Mago, they established a new Moti Mahal in Delhi's Daryaganj neighborhood.

Their tandoori chicken would become legendary. But another dish was about to make history.

A Little Leftover Ingenuity

The story goes that leftover tandoori chicken had a tendency to become dry. What could a resourceful cook do? Give it another life in a buttery, tomato-based gravy, of course!

The result was murgh makhani. Or so the story goes.

There's still considerable disagreement about exactly who invented it, and where.

But we rather love the idea of a dish born from the simple determination not to waste something delicious.

Charred tandoori chicken with lime, a block of butter and a copper bowl of tomato gravy
Butter chicken variations: a rich dark curry, a bowl of cream, dried fenugreek leaves and a bright tomato-forward bowl

How Butter Chicken Changed with the Times

There isn't one universally agreed recipe for butter chicken. Some versions emphasize the smokiness of tandoori chicken and the tang of tomatoes. Others lean into cream, butter, sweetness, or an exceptionally smooth sauce.

Over time, restaurant interpretations have become wonderfully varied. You might encounter a bright, tomato-forward gravy or one that's mellow, nutty, and indulgently rich.

Butter Chicken vs. Chicken Tikka Masala

They look remarkably alike. Both feature spiced chicken in a rich, tomato-based sauce. So what's the difference? Butter chicken is associated with the Moti Mahal tradition, while chicken tikka masala has become an icon of Britain's South Asian restaurant culture.

The latter is often described as tangier and more assertively spiced, while butter chicken tends toward a mellower, buttery richness. But in truth, both recipes overlap more than people care to admit.

Two bowls of curry side by side, a butter block and a red chili: butter chicken and chicken tikka masala
Vintage photographs of Indian restaurants and diners in the West

Butter Chicken Goes Global

Somewhere along the way, butter chicken went from a restaurant specialty to one of the world's most recognizable Indian dishes.

As South Asian restaurants flourished internationally, creamy tomato-based curries became familiar favorites for diners encountering Indian food. Today, butter chicken appears in home kitchens, restaurants, and increasingly inventive interpretations around the world.

Butter chicken pizza? Absolutely. Butter chicken pies? Why not!

When the Courts Got Involved...

How much does it matter who invented butter chicken? Quite a lot, apparently!

In 2024, the families associated with Kundan Lal Gujral and Kundan Lal Jaggi became embroiled in a legal dispute over competing claims to its invention.

The case brought restaurant records, historical photographs, and family memories into the debate. It's a fascinating reminder that food can become inseparable from questions of identity, inheritance, and ownership.

Illustrated grandmother peeking over a naan and a bowl of butter chicken
A jar of PODI life Butter Chicken Masala, limited edition blend, held by an illustrated cook

From Restaurant Kitchens to Pantry Shelves

Butter chicken has traveled a long way from those early restaurant kitchens. And somewhere along the journey, it became a dish people wanted to recreate at home.

If there's one thing butter chicken's history teaches us, it's that good recipes don't have to stand still.

↑ back to the top
Perfect pairings: butter chicken plus butter naan, pickled red onion, salad and pickle, shown with an illustrated cook and a bowl of butter chicken

Perfect pairings. Butter chicken plus: butter naan, pickled red onion, salad, pickle.

What does Butter Chicken Smell like?

Illustration of a cook breathing in a bowl of butter chicken, surrounded by butter, cardamom, tomatoes and star anise: the tell is in the smell

Butter chicken smells of warm spices, tangy tomatoes, richness, and, if you're using tandoori chicken, a hint of smoke.

But there's one ingredient that lends the dish a particularly memorable fragrance: kasuri methi, or dried fenugreek leaves. Fenugreek contains an aromatic compound called sotolon, associated with the distinctive, almost maple-syrup-like fragrance of fenugreek seeds.

In its dried leafy form, fenugreek brings an earthy, slightly bitter, almost sweet-herbal aroma that works beautifully with the richness of butter chicken. And once you recognize the fragrance of kasuri methi, you'll start noticing it in all sorts of other Indian dishes.

↑ back to the top